Freshly Handcrafted in Small Batches
Small batch production ensures that every bag of popcorn is the perfect bag of popcorn. Our products are exquisitely fresh, crafted daily and shipped within 24 to 48 hours. Each individual order is carefully inspected for quality, insuring that you receive popcorn of the highest caliber.
Non-GMO Corn
We utilize ethically sourced premium ingredients & locally sourced US grown non-GMO corn kernels.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does popcorn stay fresh?
Our gourmet popcorn is hand-crafted in small batches daily. All our items are marked with a "best before" date. Sealed bags, Crown Boxes, Jars & Ice Cream Cups stay fresh for 5 months. Acrylics & Tins stay fresh for 2 months from when they are shipped. Our artisans recommend storing uneaten portions in an air-tight container to maintain freshness.
Which popcorn flavors are gluten free?
Most of our flavors do not contain any gluten excluding Cookies and Cream & S'mores. However, we are not a gluten-free facility (yet).
Are your products vegan friendly?
We are not Vegan certified, however only our S'mores and Peppermint Hot Chocolate flavor are not vegan as they contain fish gelatin.
What dietary restrictions should I be aware of?
Products may contain coconut, soy, tree nuts & wheat. In addition, they are manufactured in a plant that processes soy, peanuts, tree nuts and wheat products. We recommend reading the nutritional information for each product prior to purchase.
How much is shipping?
Orders over $65 qualify for free standard shipping in the contiguous US with code SHIPIT Restrictions Apply. Standard shipping is $9.95+. For additional shipping options and prices see our shipping information page.
Still have questions? We'd love to help! Contact Us or call 845-357-9000 to speak with a customer care specialist.
Zvhall (verified owner) –
These little bags were such a hit at my daughter’s baby shower. There was literally only one bag left on the table. They were just the right size and obviously the taste was great. It arrived as planned and was so fresh. Love Popinsanity popcorn! Will highly recommend for other events and gifts.
John P (verified owner) –
Great popcorn very tasty
Sue F (verified owner) –
We love caramel corn and thought it would make a great party favor for a baby shower. This came beautifully packaged with an elegant label. Attention to detail is clearly evident and they arrived even ahead of schedule during a busy holiday time. Would order from them again as it made a great gift.
Kim H (verified owner) –
I received the wrong popcorn initially. Customer service was very helpful and sent me the correct order.
I absolutely loved the popcorn. I had been scouring the earth for a vegan caramel popcorn as I recently found that I have a dairy allergy. I will definitely be ordering again!
Kada (verified owner) –
Have tasted many popcorns claiming caramel and while some come close this is the best flavor, coating type and popped quality ever tasted. Should come with a ‘difficult to stop’ warning!
Goes down just right.
Tiffany (verified owner) –
I love and enjoy eating the classic caramel popcorn. The sweetness is just right as it is not too sweet. Great for snacking!
Tova (verified owner) –
Add this to your Shabbos table or shaloch manos. The perfect amount of sweet in the perfect size.
Samantha F –
Best caramel popcorn on the market! Sweet and salty all in one! has plenty of caramel on each piece and still has crunch! Absolutely delicious!
Diana B (verified owner) –
Give it as gifts for the last 4 years and everyone LOVES it!! I always order extra as some stay home for me!!!
Sara (verified owner) –
It might be called classic but there is nothing classic about this popcorn, it is so fresh and perfectly flavored!
Warren W (verified owner) –
I received a bag of your popcorn as part of a Christmas gift bag. This was my second or third and I’m sure it will not be my last!
Cherie (verified owner) –
The quality of the popcorn was excellent. Unfortunately the caramel tasted burnt in several bags. If future batches don’t taste burnt it’s 100% top notch. Delivery was excellent also. And the bag size was perfect.
Victoria M (verified owner) –
Omg! Can we just say the BEST!!!! I had my first bag maybe a month ago from a store I got it from and then 2 days later ordered 3 bags, Now I’m placing another order! It’s honestly the best I’ve ever had.
Heidy I (verified owner) –
The best caramel popcorn I’ve had!
Linda M (verified owner) –
This is by far the best caramel popcorn I have ever tasted. Since I am 70yo, that is saying a lot. I love it and do not place an order without it. Thank you!
Heidi F (verified owner) –
Perfect flavor and perfect size. My new favorite snack!
Marty G (verified owner) –
Perfection in popcorn. Our new addiction. Always have a few reserve bags on hand.
Marge P (verified owner) –
Very classic and crunchy!
Lily (verified owner) –
So happy with this regular flavor. Kind of wish they would make a dairy free cheddar. That’s what I’m really missing. Either way, this caramel is delicious. Everything is so worth the price.
LaMarva I (verified owner) –
Amazingly delicious and addictive… can’t stop eating it!
Susan R (verified owner) –
All of Popinsanity Popcorn I have purchased is excellent and I have been buying it for the last three years. This is a new one for me and it is delicious. Everyone should try this you will really love the taste.
JYG (verified owner) –
OMG so so good. We all loved it.
Karen B (verified owner) –
priced right, fresh, quick delivery and delicious.
Janet A (verified owner) –
Amazing!
Sue S (verified owner) –
The Carmel Popcorn is absolutely delicious and very addictive!!!
Sue S (verified owner) –
The Caramel Popcorn is delicious!!! In fact I take a Serving each time I walk by the glass container! Fabulous product!!!
Sue S (verified owner) –
The Carmel popcorn is absolutely delicious and very addictive!!!!!
Karen (verified owner) –
This is a good caramel corn
gina (verified owner) –
They do everything right. Great tasting popcorn.